olegs/ai_tools_analysis
1
0 Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

Update evaluations and documentation for Claude Code and Google Antigravity; expand tool counts and enhance enterprise compatibility details.

Browse Source
This commit is contained in:
olegs committed 2026-02-02 14:30:25 +02:00
1 parent 194a79bb17
commit 7d6bc20276
8 files changed
+776 -32
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

No files matched your search

evaluation_development_google_antigravity.md
+320
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,320 @@
# Google Antigravity - Enterprise Compatibility Evaluation
## Overview
Google Antigravity is an AI-powered agentic IDE (Integrated Development Environment) launched in November 2025 alongside Gemini 3. Built as a modified fork of Visual Studio Code, it features an "agent-first" design where AI agents can autonomously make changes, run code, and verify their work. The platform is powered by Gemini 3 Pro, Gemini 3 Deep Think, and Gemini 3 Flash models.
## Enterprise/Commercial Use Permission
**Status: YES - Permitted (Currently in Public Preview)**
Google Antigravity permits commercial use, with Team and Enterprise plans anticipated in 2026. Currently available as a free Public Preview with rate limits.
**Key Points:**
- Public Preview is free for all developers
- Code generated by agents belongs to the user
- Team and Enterprise plans coming 2026
- Google does not guarantee generated code is free from third-party rights
**Sources:**
- https://developers.googleblog.com/build-with-google-antigravity-our-new-agentic-development-platform/
- https://antigravity.google/terms
---
## Data Training Policies
### Public Preview (Free Tier)
**Status: AMBIGUOUS - CAUTION ADVISED**
**Current State:**
- "Telemetry" toggle available but doesn't prevent code transmission
- AI inference must happen in cloud - code is transmitted
- Language around "product improvement" is ambiguous
- **No zero-retention guarantee** during Preview
**Key Concerns:**
> "The Preview offers no zero-retention guarantee, and code could be used for training."
> "Disabling 'Telemetry' doesn't prevent code transmission—AI inference must happen in the cloud."
### Google AI Pro/Ultra Subscribers
**Better Protections:**
> "For Team tiers: Your code snippets are not used to train Google's public models. This is non-negotiable for commercial work."
### Anticipated Enterprise Tier
**Expected Features:**
- No training on customer code
- Data residency options
- Enhanced privacy controls
- SSO and admin controls
**Sources:**
- https://www.baytechconsulting.com/blog/google-antigravity-ai-ide-2026
- https://cension.ai/blog/google-antigravity-ai-what-is-it/
---
## Data Retention and Sharing Policies
**Current (Public Preview):**
- No published zero-retention policy
- Data retained according to Google Antigravity Privacy Policy
- Users may request data export within 30 days of termination
**Anticipated Enterprise:**
- Google Workspace enterprise customers typically get:
- Enterprise-grade security and compliance
- Data remains private
- No sharing with third parties for training
**Data Location:**
- Processed within Google Cloud infrastructure
- Enterprise may have data residency options
**Important Limitation:**
> "There's no SOC 2 report yet; Google promises compliance at GA, but currently lacks IP indemnification and zero-retention guarantees."
---
## IP and Confidentiality Concerns
**Intellectual Property:**
- **Code Ownership**: Users own generated code
- **No Guarantee**: Google does not guarantee code is free from third-party rights
- **User Responsibility**: Users responsible for license compliance
**Confidentiality Risks:**
**Security Warnings in Terms of Service:**
> "Security is an issue, and the terms of use warn that 'Antigravity is known to have certain security limitations.' Risks identified include data exfiltration and code execution."
**Agent Access Concerns:**
> "By default, Antigravity agents have autonomous access to your terminal, filesystem, and network connections."
**Execution Modes:**
1. **Automatic execution**: Agents run all commands without approval
2. **Agent-assisted** (default): AI decides when to ask for approval
3. **Require approval**: Every command needs human authorization
**Recommendation for Enterprise:**
> "For clients in regulated industries (Healthcare, Finance), Antigravity should be treated as a public cloud environment. Do not use it for codebases containing PII or hardcoded secrets until a formal BAA covers the tool."
**Compliance Status:**
- No SOC 2 report yet (promised at GA)
- No IP indemnification currently
- Google Cloud infrastructure (inherits some certifications)
---
## Gemini Quota Relationship
### Key Question: Are Antigravity and Gemini Limits Shared?
**Finding: PARTIALLY SHARED / COMPLEX**
**Evidence:**
> "The quota for Gemini 2.5 Pro got merged with the quota for Gemini 3 Pro, creating a single shared quota for both models - if 50% is used with Gemini 3 Pro, only 50% remains for both models."
**Separate Systems:**
- Antigravity uses "work done" based limits (task complexity)
- Gemini app uses prompt-based limits
- Gemini Code Assist agent mode and CLI quotas are combined
**Rate Limit Refresh:**
| Tier | Antigravity Refresh | Gemini App |
|------|-------------------|------------|
| Free | Weekly | Daily |
| AI Pro | Every 5 hours | Higher daily |
| AI Ultra | Every 5 hours (highest) | Highest daily |
**Bottom Line:**
- Google AI Pro/Ultra subscription improves both Antigravity AND Gemini limits
- Quotas appear to be tracked separately but subscription tier affects both
- Heavy Antigravity usage does NOT appear to drain Gemini app quota directly
- However, some model-level quotas (Gemini 3 Pro) may be shared across products
**Sources:**
- https://blog.google/feed/new-antigravity-rate-limits-pro-ultra-subsribers/
- https://github.com/google-gemini/gemini-cli/issues/15248
- https://developers.google.com/gemini-code-assist/resources/quotas
---
## Free Tier Details
**Public Preview (Free)**
**Features Included:**
- Full Antigravity IDE access
- Gemini 3 Pro model
- Unlimited tab code completions
- Agent Manager
- Browser integration
- Manager view for multi-agent workflows
- Artifacts (task lists, implementation plans, screenshots)
**Limits:**
- Weekly-based rate limit (refreshes once per week)
- Limits based on "work done" not request count
- Complex tasks consume more quota
- No published specific limits
**Privacy Concerns:**
- No zero-retention guarantee
- Code may be used for improvement
- Telemetry toggle doesn't prevent code transmission
---
## Paid Plans (Current via Google AI Subscription)
### Google AI Pro
**Price:** $19.99/month
**Antigravity Benefits:**
- Priority access
- Highest rate limits
- 5-hour refresh cycle (vs weekly for free)
- Code not used for training public models
**Gemini Benefits:**
- Higher Gemini app limits
- Access to Gemini 3 Pro/Ultra models
---
### Google AI Ultra
**Price:** $24.99/month (previously $249.99/year)
**Antigravity Benefits:**
- 20x higher limits than Pro
- Highest priority access
- 5-hour refresh cycle
- Multi-agent workflows at scale
- Code not used for training
**Gemini Benefits:**
- Highest Gemini limits
- All Gemini features
---
### Anticipated Pricing (2026)
| Plan | Expected Price | Features |
|------|---------------|----------|
| Individual | Free | Rate limited |
| Pro | ~$20/month | Higher limits, priority |
| Team | TBD | SSO, admin controls |
| Enterprise | ~$40-60/user/month | Data residency, compliance |
**Pricing Model Shift:**
> "We are no longer paying for 'code completion.' We are paying for 'autonomous hours.'"
**Compute Credits:**
- Intensive tasks may require additional "High-Density Compute Credits"
- Similar to Claude's usage-based approach
---
## Usage Limits
### How Limits Work:
> "Google Antigravity usage limits aren't calculated by the number of requests or lines of code written. Instead, the rate limits are based on 'work done' by Antigravity's AI agent."
### Rate Limit Details:
- **Simple tasks**: Lower quota consumption
- **Complex reasoning/refactoring**: Higher quota consumption
- **Multi-file operations**: Highest consumption
### Refresh Cycles:
- **Free**: Weekly refresh
- **AI Pro/Ultra**: 5-hour refresh
### Known Issues:
- Some users report 4-7 day lockouts due to bugs
- Cannot query remaining quota directly from agent
- EU region users may experience lower quotas
---
## Summary Recommendation
### Current Assessment (Public Preview):
**Strengths:**
- Powerful agentic AI development capabilities
- Free during preview period
- Manager view for multi-agent workflows
- Built on proven Gemini 3 models
- Google Cloud infrastructure
**Critical Concerns:**
- **No SOC 2 certification yet**
- **No zero-retention guarantee**
- **Code may be used for training (unclear policy)**
- **Security limitations acknowledged in ToS**
- **No IP indemnification**
- **Autonomous agent access to filesystem/terminal**
### Recommendation Matrix:
| Use Case | Recommendation | Reason |
|----------|---------------|--------|
| Personal projects | ✅ OK to use | Low risk, free |
| Learning/experimentation | ✅ OK to use | No sensitive data |
| New hackathon projects | ⚠️ Use with caution | No existing IP at risk |
| Enterprise codebase | 🚨 NOT RECOMMENDED | No compliance guarantees |
| Regulated industry | 🚨 DO NOT USE | No BAA, no SOC 2 |
| Sensitive/classified code | 🚨 DO NOT USE | Security limitations |
### For Enterprise Adoption:
**Wait for GA Release (2026) when Google provides:**
- [ ] SOC 2 Type II certification
- [ ] Zero data retention option
- [ ] Clear no-training policy
- [ ] IP indemnification
- [ ] BAA for healthcare
- [ ] Enterprise terms of service
**Current Alternative:** Use **Google Gemini Code Assist** (Standard/Enterprise) which has established enterprise protections, or **Continue.dev** for air-gapped requirements.
---
## Comparison: Antigravity vs Gemini Code Assist
| Feature | Antigravity | Gemini Code Assist |
|---------|------------|-------------------|
| Maturity | Public Preview | Production |
| SOC 2 | Not yet | Yes |
| Enterprise Terms | Coming 2026 | Available |
| Training Policy | Ambiguous | Clear no-training |
| Pricing | Free (preview) | $19-47/user/month |
| Agent Capabilities | Full agentic | Limited |
---
## Verification Checklist
Before implementing, verify the following:
- [ ] Current preview terms at https://antigravity.google/terms
- [ ] GA release date and enterprise features
- [ ] SOC 2 certification status
- [ ] Training policy clarification
- [ ] Enterprise pricing when available
- [ ] Data residency options
---
**Last Updated:** February 2, 2026
**Additional Sources:**
- [Google Developers Blog - Antigravity Announcement](https://developers.googleblog.com/build-with-google-antigravity-our-new-agentic-development-platform/)
- [Google AI Subscription Features](https://9to5google.com/2026/01/16/google-ai-pro-ultra-features/)
- [Antigravity Rate Limits](https://blog.google/feed/new-antigravity-rate-limits-pro-ultra-subsribers/)
**Note:** Google Antigravity is in Public Preview. Policies, features, and pricing will change at GA release. Enterprise users should wait for official enterprise tier before processing sensitive code.